LOGIN
User Name
Password
Remember me


> Not a member yet?
> Forgot your password?
Main menu
Preferred site
Get Firefox!
Forum Message
Country:US
Membership23years 140days ago.
Last Login1year 166days ago.
Last Move2years 151days ago.
Electro is currently Offline!Send a mail to Electro

Message header
Area/Game:Wooden Ships & Iron Men
1Topic:How to play
Subject:Re: Resolving melees
Posted by: Electro - 5years 127days ago.
Message text
This is what Derek sent me in January of this year, but I thought BlueDragon resolved these:

The main issue is when a losing OBP somehow gets "transferred" to, and capture, a Ship that was vacated by a successful OBP. An example: Ship A grapples or fouls Ship B. Both Ships elect to do OBPs, with Ship A using ALL remaining Crew Sections. Ship A wins the melee and transfers ALL their crew to Ship B. BUT, instead of Ship A's Player now controlling BOTH Ship A and Ship B, the losing OBP from Ship B is mistakenly placed on Ship A; and since Ship A is void of crew, Ship B's Player incorrectly owns Ship A. (This bug happens more often when there are more than 2 Ships involved in a single melee).

Part of the issue seems to be that the code places OBPs on their target Ships in all, or many, cases. This “transfer” should only happen for the winning OBP. I say this, as sometimes I see “prisoners” that end up being placed on ships other than that of their “Ship of Origin.”

The more common version of the bug occurs when two Ships both send an OBP to a single target Ship, and the single Ship OBPs one or both of their opponents. In this case, there exists the possibility that the code is NOT doing the boarding as a single melee, as the rules state. Multiple OBPs coming at a single target are to be treated as one OBP; therefore, even if the target ship sends counter OBPs at each enemy Ship, it is to be fought as one big melee.
Messages thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

5years 127days KapteinKnutsen Resolving melees
5years 127days Electro Re: Resolving melees
5years 127days KapteinKnutsen Re: Resolving melees
 5years 127days derekticus Re: Resolving melees
  5years 127days KapteinKnutsen Re: Resolving melees
   5years 126days KapteinKnutsen Re: Resolving melees
5years 127days Electro Re: Resolving melees
5years 122days BlueDragon Re: Resolving melees
Page generated in: 14.45313 milliseconds.