http://www.youplay.it/beta/play/ws_GameMove.asp?GameID=1954&UserID=ResistiIf I understand well the rule, now(and since previous turn)the Duc Bougogne should surrender, since Royal Oak is raking her, and there is no friendly(French) ship within 10 hexes.
This doesn't seem the case...
So?
May I guess that the game is not properly recognizing friends and foes? In such a case it could well be that Adamant(english) is keeping the french ship still in play....