LOGIN
User Name
Password
Remember me


Register...Forgot password?
Main menu
Leagues
Gonzaga
Blue Max
Cartagena
Wooden Ships...
King Me!
VampiRing
Forum Message
Previous messagePost on the new forumNext message

Country:CX
Personal Data:Male, born: June 17 1960
HomePage or other cool site:http://www.boardgamegeek.com
Membership19years 94days ago.
Last Login31days 2h ago.
Last Move85days 20h ago.
derekticus is currently Offline!


Message header
Area/Game:Wooden Ships & Iron Men
Topic:Rules
Subject:Re: Doubt about Boarding Actions
Posted by: derekticus - 16years 253days ago.
Message text
Odeiiii wrote:
Good day, Admirals.

In a game I'm playing, during a boarding action something that I didn't expect happened and I'd like to know why. The situation now is the following:

http://www.youplay.it/play/ws_GameMove.asp?GameID=527989&MoveId=22

Just before the Boarding Phase, Ville de Paris (French) was grappled to Fier (French), Formidable (British) and Terrible (British), and their crews were as follows (all average):

Fier (French): 8
Ville de Paris (French): 10

Formidable (British): 6
Terrible (British): 6

Knowing that, I ordered Ville de Paris' whole crew (10) to board Terrible (in hopes it would be able to capture it) while transferred Fier's (8) to Ville de Paris to defend it against the boarding party Formidable would surely send (6).

However, apparently Fier's crew never fought against Formidable's boarding party, as this (according to the turn report) captured Ville de Paris without any melee. Even worse, both Fier's and Ville de Paris's crews (the latter was not eventually able to seize Terrible) were also captured.

The only explanation I can think about what actually happened is that crew movements don't happen simultaneously, but offensive boarding is first, then melees, and at last transfers.

Could anybody confirm whether it is so, or explain me how boarding phase actually works? Or is it another bug?

I will appreciate any help.

Odei


Yes, you have struck on complications with the rules.

OBPs go first, and they battle OBPs of their target ship first. Then OBPs battle DBPs of their target ship. Then, once all battle is complete, TBPs move as ordered. Transfers never fight or do anything on the turn they transfer. They are in limbo, busy packing up their meager belongings and getting shuttled to their new assignment.
So, what happened is only slightly incorrect in my current understanding of the rules.
Ville OBPed and was repulsed, so that OBP must return to Ville. Meanwhile, Ville was captured, so the Ville OBP became prisoners. All that I can accept, although I will re-read the rules, as some might argue that the Ville OBP should have engaged both their target and the Fromidable's OBP simultaneously.
For me the only bug is the capture of the TBP. Since the TBP was scheduled to move to the Ville at the end of the phase, they should have remained at home since the Ville was effectively in enemy hands prior to their transfer.

Back to the messages list
Messages thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

16years 254days Odeiiii [WS&IM][RULES] Doubt about Boarding Actions
16years 253days derekticus Re: [WS&IM][RULES] Doubt about Boarding Actions
16years 253days Longneck Re: [WS&IM][RULES] Doubt about Boarding Actions
 16years 253days derekticus Re: [WS&IM][RULES] Doubt about Boarding Actions
  16years 253days Longneck Re: [WS&IM][RULES] Doubt about Boarding Actions
   16years 253days derekticus Re: [WS&IM][RULES] Doubt about Boarding Actions
   16years 252days Odeiiii Re: [WS&IM][RULES] Doubt about Boarding Actions
   16years 253days sfatula Re: [WS&IM][RULES] Doubt about Boarding Actions
16years 253days JakobSperling Re: [WS&IM][RULES] Doubt about Boarding Actions
 16years 252days sfatula Re: [WS&IM][RULES] Doubt about Boarding Actions
 16years 252days derekticus Re: [WS&IM][RULES] Doubt about Boarding Actions
Next thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

16years 255days Ray_Collishaw [BM][RULES] Last alive
16years 255days BlackSheep Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
 16years 253days pokerguy Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
  16years 252days GraysGhost Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
   16years 251days TXWard Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
    16years 251days GraysGhost Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
     16years 251days TXWard Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
     16years 251days dcr66 Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
      16years 251days GraysGhost Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
       16years 251days dcr66 Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
       16years 251days TXWard Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
        16years 251days GraysGhost Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
         16years 251days litehoof Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
          16years 251days GraysGhost Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
           16years 251days pokerguy Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
            16years 250days BMBug Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
             16years 250days TXWard Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
              16years 250days BMBug Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
               16years 250days TXWard Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
                16years 250days BMBug Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
                 16years 250days TXWard Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
                  16years 250days BMBug Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
                   16years 250days TXWard Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
                    16years 250days pokerguy Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
                    16years 250days GraysGhost Re: [BM][RULES] Last alive
Previous thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

16years 268days Odeiiii [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
16years 267days derekticus Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
16years 266days tlamb67 Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
16years 266days dcr66 Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
 16years 266days tlamb67 Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
  16years 266days dcr66 Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
   16years 261days Odeiiii Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
    16years 261days derekticus Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
    16years 260days Odeiiii Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
    16years 261days dcr66 Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
     16years 260days Odeiiii Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
      16years 260days derekticus Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
      16years 259days Odeiiii Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
      16years 260days dcr66 Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
       16years 259days Odeiiii Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
       16years 259days dcr66 Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
       16years 259days bltzlfsk Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
        16years 258days Odeiiii Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
         16years 258days dcr66 Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
          16years 257days Odeiiii Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
           16years 257days dcr66 Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
           16years 256days Odeiiii Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
           16years 257days sfatula Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
            16years 257days derekticus Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
            16years 256days Odeiiii Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
             16years 256days derekticus Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
              16years 254days Odeiiii Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
               16years 254days derekticus Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
                16years 254days Odeiiii Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
            16years 256days Odeiiii Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
16years 259days karllagov Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
 16years 258days dcr66 Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
 16years 258days karllagov Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
  16years 258days sfatula Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
 16years 258days Odeiiii Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
 16years 258days dcr66 Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
 16years 257days Odeiiii Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
  16years 257days dcr66 Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
   16years 256days Odeiiii Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
 16years 257days karllagov Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
 16years 258days sfatula Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
  16years 257days karllagov Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
   16years 257days sfatula Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
    16years 256days Templars Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
     16years 256days sfatula Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
     16years 254days Odeiiii Re: [WS&IM][BUG] Surrender Bug: Ethic of Opportunity Surrendering
Page generated in: 35.9375 milliseconds.