LOGIN
User Name
Password
Remember me


> Not a member yet?
> Forgot your password?
Main menu
Preferred site
Get Firefox!
Forum Message
City:Cairo EG
Personal Data:Male,
Membership16years 210days ago.
Last Login12years 215days ago.
Last Move12years 216days ago.
karllagov is currently Offline!Send a mail to karllagov

Message header
Area/Game:Wooden Ships & Iron Men
1Topic:Bugs and Improvements
Subject:Re: Struck ships
Posted by: karllagov - 14years 37days ago.
Message text
BlueDragon wrote:
karllagov wrote:

Here is an inconsistency:
1) My crew captured another ship. Next turn, I was able to return to my now crewless ship (no grappling, no fouling) without problem.

2) My opponent captured one of my ships. Now his original ship was crewless. However, I cannot transfer crew without grappling/fouling.

Both scenarios involve crewless ships, in both scenarios the situation is handled differently.

No inconsistency, this is the common case that you can transfer between your ships without grappling, while you need grappling to capture to enemy ships.
By game rules, crewless ship are not surrendered and do not lose ownership, thus they still require grappling to be boarded.
I agree that it is somewhat confusing here on Youplay as we give score and use the surrender flag when you make an enemy ship crewless.


That makes no sense. How can a crewless ship belong to someone? Ok, for scoring. But it shouldn't be treated differently, it's an empty hulk floating around. Each crew needs to grapple or not but should be treated equally.
Messages thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

14years 40days karllagov Struck ships
14years 40days BlueDragon Re: Struck ships
 14years 39days karllagov Re: Struck ships
 14years 38days karllagov Re: Struck ships
  14years 38days BlueDragon Re: Struck ships
   14years 37days karllagov Re: Struck ships
    14years 32days Longneck Re: Struck ships
     14years 31days BlueDragon Re: Struck ships
      14years 31days karllagov Re: Struck ships
Page generated in: 14.0625 milliseconds.