BlackSheep wrote:
It would be nice if you keep a record of which scenarios has played each player, just to decide if we must put a limit to some scenarios which have a decided winner from the start.
I already have a way to see which scenarios have been played 
Anyway:
* Unbalanced scenarios:
from a certain point of view, it's not possible to "abuse" a certain scenario freely, since for every "trap" game you create, you need someone to join it and fall into the trap
So if the Allied choose to create 100 games of "Feb 17 - Here comes the Navy - 2 Players" it's still German's responsability to fly into the trap or not.
I know that some people will "randomly" join it.. so most of the traps will work sooner or later even if some of the most commited people to the campaign will avoid it.
This brings us to ther other point: the other side can do the same and set scenario "traps" as well! Infact, I believe that some of the advantage Germans got into the first weeks (and even on March 1917 when Triplane was already available) was due to the choice of scenarios which actually favored Germans.
Obviously that wasn't so glaring and obvious as what is happening now, as the scenarios used where more varied than the single 1vs1 scenario which is so popular at the moment.
So back to the point, both sides can set their traps so overall the situation can be thought as still fair.
The question might be: do we want to win by traps or by fighting more or less equally on open field?
It's up to both sides to decide what they want to do, and maybe make some mutual agreement...take it as part of the war process 
PS: Here's the list of scenarios played:
#Played PointsAllied PointsGerman scenario
70 3094 1802 (2 players) Feb 17 - Here comes the Navy - 2 Players
18 665 653 (2 players) The Cobra Tournament, 2 Players
12 778 824 (3 players) Richthofens DIII
11 785 483 (3 players) early war (version 2)
11 1002 1550 (5 players) 4 guns vs. 3
10 503 357 (2 players) Flying targets 1, 2 players
10 652 815 (4 players) Feb 17 - Here comes the Navy - 4 players
8 389 330 (3 players) Early war, 3 players
8 375 686 (4 players) WWI campaign (part 3)
8 891 1179 (6 players) Early war, 6 players
7 248 228 (2 players) Escadrille Americaine 2 players
6 230 237 (2 players) Spad V Schuckert
5 614 710 (6 players) Early war (part 3)
5 700 586 (6 players) Jan 17 - You got guns, we got number - 6 players
5 1128 545 (8 players) Oh Tripes
4 148 238 (3 players) Triplane out gunned!!
4 933 915 (9 players) Nine to Mortal Men, part 2
3 97 60 (2 players) Two gun is megl che one - part II
3 69 150 (3 players) Albatross surprised????? (Idea from Darken)
3 451 428 (5 players) Albatross supreme????
3 285 406 (6 players) Jan 1917
2 110 105 (3 players) SpadVII v Schuckerts
2 88 213 (5 players) Naval Hunters
2 180 357 (6 players) all things being equal (abridged version)
2 364 562 (8 players) Oh Tripes?
1 6 51 (3 players) Albatross hunting???
1 42 111 (4 players) Shuckert fodder????
1 268 115 (8 players) Equilibrium maintained
|
Donate
Leagues
Gonzaga
Blue Max
Cartagena
Wooden Ships...
King Me!
VampiRing
