In this game:
http://www.youplay.it/beta/play/ws_GameMove.asp?GameID=23823&UserID=Longneckon turn 50 Duc shot at Befford's hull from a range of 7 hexes. The damage is right for the HDT and die roll, but it's on the hull side!
Also, HDT 3 is wrong. For just the 17 bow guns, it should've been HDT -1. I'm wondering if it's confused by the nearby Romulus, for which hull HDT 3 would be right.